Picture: Facebook

George Orwell’s Animal Farm warned about the hypocrisy of political elites who claim to fight for equality, only to end up living lives of privilege themselves.

In the novel, the pigs gradually take over the farmhouse, enjoy luxuries denied to the other animals, and eventually become indistinguishable from the ruling class they once condemned.

That comparison is becoming increasingly hard to ignore in modern Australia.

There’s something disturbingly hypocritical about unions demanding Australians pay MORE tax, while unions pay little or no income tax and generally no Capital Gains Tax.

The Australian union movement is currently cheering changes to Capital Gains Tax concessions and negative gearing, claiming:

“We should tax wealth the same way we tax work.”

Really?

Let’s talk about how union wealth and how they are taxed.

In Australia, unions are generally exempt from income tax if they qualify as tax-exempt employee or employer associations under tax law. Because capital gains are normally part of assessable income, a fully tax-exempt union will generally also be exempt from Capital Gains Tax (CGT) on assets it owns.

That means many unions can, and do, accumulate enormous asset bases, property portfolios and investment holdings while paying little or no tax on gains.

Meanwhile, ordinary Australians who work hard, save money, invest in property, take risks, pay mortgages, pay land tax, council rates, stamp duty and maintenance costs are increasingly being told they should pay even MORE tax.

The irony is gobsmacking.

Many unions today are no longer struggling grassroots organisations run from modest offices. Some control vast investment interests, commercial operations, property holdings and industry funds worth billions of dollars collectively.

Yet they continue to enjoy significant tax advantages because they are treated as “not-for-profit” organisations.

And we can’t ignore the political connection.

Australian unions are among the biggest financial backers of the Labor Party.

Millions of dollars flow from unions into Labor campaigns, advertising, staffing and political infrastructure.

The relationship between unions and Labor is foundational.

Australians are entitled to ask an important question: Are these tax policy changes really about fairness, or are they about ideology and political power?

Because the people promoting higher taxes on investors and property owners are often people who have personally benefited enormously from the very system they now want to restrict for others.

Take Prime Minister Anthony Albanese as an example.

Anthony Albanese has benefited from negative gearing, property ownership and Australia’s Capital Gains Tax system over many years. He climbed the property ladder, built wealth through real estate and today owns a luxury beachside home for which he is reported to pay $4.3 million (plus stamp duty), while also benefiting from rental income and generous taxpayer-funded parliamentary superannuation arrangements.

There’s nothing wrong with success, property investment or building wealth.

The problem here is the double standard.

Do as I say, not what I do. 

Many young Australians are now being told that the same pathways to wealth creation used by previous generations should be restricted, taxed more heavily or effectively closed off.

Negative gearing and the CGT discount helped many Australians build financial security, create retirement income and reduce pressure on the pension system.

For decades, ordinary middle-income Australians — not just the wealthy — invested in property as one of the few reliable ways to get ahead.

Now the ladder is being pulled up behind them by Anthony Albanese and Jim Chalmers, while being cheered on by their hypocritical Union masters..

And while politicians, unions and wealthy institutional players sit on substantial assets and investments, everyday Australians are increasingly portrayed as greedy or selfish simply for wanting to own an investment property.

The reality is that many property investors are not billionaires.

They are teachers, tradies, nurses, small business owners and PAYG workers trying to create a better future for themselves and their families.

They already pay enormous amounts of tax:

• Income tax

• GST

• Stamp duty

• Land tax

• Council rates

• Capital Gains Tax

• Interest costs

• Insurance

• Maintenance and compliance costs

Yet they are constantly targeted as though they are the problem.

Meanwhile, many unions themselves pay little or no tax due to their special tax-exempt status.

Of course, there are exceptions.

If a union operates a taxable subsidiary or commercial entity, that separate entity may pay CGT. If a union loses or does not qualify for tax-exempt status, CGT can apply. Certain transactions involving non-exempt activities or investment structures may still create taxable liabilities.

The rules are governed by the Australian Taxation Office under the Income Tax Assessment Acts.

So in practice:

• Most registered unions themselves generally do not pay CGT because they are income-tax exempt entities.

• But associated commercial operations or non-exempt entities can.

The broader issue here is fairness and consistency.

Why should tax-exempt organisations with major financial influence lecture ordinary Australians about “paying their fair share”?

Why should governments punish aspiration while rewarding politically connected organisations that enjoy significant tax advantages themselves?

And why are younger Australians being denied the same opportunities previous generations used to build wealth?

Australians are becoming increasingly frustrated with double standards.

Hard work, investment, entrepreneurship and sensible risk-taking built this country. Wealth creation should not become something to be demonised simply because it is politically convenient.

If unions genuinely believe “wealth should be taxed the same way as work,” perhaps they should begin by voluntarily giving up their own generous tax exemptions first.

SUGGESTED ARTICLES